Close
Menu
  1. Home /
  2. Our work /
  3. Wallsauce – CRO testing
Wallsauce

Improving conversion across Wallsauce’s made-to-measure ecommerce journey

  • Conversion Rate Optimisation
  • Strategy
  • 137
    Increase in product click-throughs
  • 55
    Increase in desktop checkout conversions

The Diagnosis

Helping more wall mural shoppers complete a complex, made-to-measure buying journey

Wallsauce is a Lancashire-based online retailer of made-to-measure wallpaper murals. The business has built a large catalogue of artist-led designs. Customers can also turn their own photos into murals, and choose between paste-the-wall materials and peel-and-stick options for renters. Wallsauce sells to homes and businesses worldwide.

Every mural is printed to the customer’s exact wall dimensions, so the product configurator sits at the centre of every sale. It’s where shoppers measure their wall, crop the image and choose a material. That process has to feel clear and reassuring, especially on a phone.

Wallsauce wanted a higher conversion rate, to get more value from existing traffic and support more advertising spend. Our early research found friction in three places: the configurator, product discovery across thousands of designs, and the mobile journey. Our objective was to help more shoppers find the right mural, configure it confidently and complete checkout.

The Approach

Using data, UX research and client insight to prioritise the highest-value test.

We started by building an evidence base. Our UX and analytics team cleaned up Wallsauce’s Google Analytics setup and ran heuristic research. They then built a prioritisation matrix that ranked each opportunity by its evidence and likely commercial impact, so every test had a clear reason to exist.

Wallsauce brought strong instincts about its brand and customers. The team knew murals sell best when shown in real room settings, so we carried that into category, listing and hero imagery. Where views differed on a design choice, we agreed on a practical middle ground and let the test decide.

The programme ran in two phases. The first focused on the desktop product page, category pages, product listings and navigation. As the data built up, mobile became the main priority, and the second phase concentrated on mobile showcasing, navigation and the configurator steps. Checkout conversion was the headline measure throughout, which kept design decisions tied to sales.

The Execution

Building tests around Wallsauce’s custom CMS and in-house development team

Wallsauce’s custom-built CMS made most ideas technically possible, but every test had to fit the business’s own development and release process. Wallsauce’s in-house developer controlled implementation, so Door4 designed and built tests to move into production with as little rework as possible.

First-phase tests ran client-side in VWO. For the mobile tests, we moved to server-side testing. We built the variants directly in Wallsauce’s codebase and checked them on shared development and staging environments before release.

We also changed how designs were reviewed. To bring feedback in earlier, we swapped email review for on-site workshops, where designs were amended and signed off in the room. Built tests then only needed functional QA. We also:

  • Briefed Wallsauce’s developer at the start of each test.
  • Used a common communication channel.
  • Documented the server-side testing process.

That developer-to-developer relationship turned delivery into a shared process.

The Success Criteria

Measuring success through checkout conversion and the behaviours behind it

Checkout conversion was the headline measure across the programme and the basis for the biggest wins. The desktop product page redesign delivered a 55% uplift. Four second-phase tests, mostly on mobile, delivered uplifts of 137% to 327%.

Each test also tracked its own primary goal, matched to the problem it was solving, such as add-to-basket clicks, product page views or interaction with each configurator step. For a made-to-measure product, configurator progress mattered most. We tracked how many users moved through measuring, cropping and material selection, and where they dropped out.

Product page reach mattered too, especially on mobile, because shoppers had to get deeper into the catalogue before they could configure a mural. Where a test changed the later stages of the journey, we monitored basket-to-checkout progression. That protected sales while we tested bolder UX changes.

Client outcomes & beyond

A stronger conversion journey and a clear roadmap for future e-commerce growth

The programme produced eight winning tests and an estimated 3.8x return on Wallsauce’s investment, calculated on a conservative basis.

The desktop product page redesign was the first big win, lifting checkout conversion by 55%. Supporting signals moved the same way: width clicks rose 10%, “set mural size” clicks rose 40% and add to basket clicks rose 3.6%. The new design was then implemented on the live site.

Changes to category pages, product listings and the main navigation helped shoppers find products faster. In the second phase, the four winning tests improved:

  • Mobile Configurator Steps
    • Improvements to the product configurator for Mobile users (over 60% of users), seeing a +327% increase in these steps completed
  • Mobile Showcasing
    • A test targeting the showcasing of the product and lifestyle imagery on Mobile category and product listing pages, leading to a +137% increase in product click-throughs
  • Product Page Accordion Structure (+166%)
    • Improved Product detail page content structures to allow for more digestible information, seeing a +166% increase in configurator starts
  • Navigation Between Product Pages (+225%)
    • Targeting the relationship and inspiration between products in related themes to encourage more engagement throughout the catalogue, leading to product page clicks from one another increasing by 225%

Each test achieved a 90% level of statistical significance before implementation.

Wallsauce now has a tested picture of where conversion friction sits and which changes create commercial uplift. It also has a repeatable process for making future e-commerce decisions based on evidence.

Does this kind of success work for you?

If you'd like to work with a performance marketing agency that will help you exceed your commercial goals, we can start on it right away. Get in touch.

Proud to work with