We brought together insights from our Door4 practitioners who plan and optimise seasonal campaigns at pace. This article blends their lived experience with our research on where retail and marketing ops are heading.
In a cost-conscious climate, shoppers are better equipped and far less impulsive than in the early Black Friday glory years. Price trackers and deal alerts have levelled the field. Brands cannot rely on chaos or novelty. They have to earn attention with genuine value.
NRF and Adobe Analytics have both pointed to solid holiday volumes in recent years, with growth moderated by price sensitivity and a shift toward value hunting. The signal for operators is simple. Cyber Week is no longer a one-day land grab. It is a controlled campaign window where transparency, timing and unit economics decide the winners.
As Tom Morton, Head of Activation here at Door4, told us, the theatre has changed, but the substance matters more than ever.
Black Friday and Cyber Week don’t really hold the same magic they used to. It’s gone from people queuing at 4am and fighting over TVs to afairly drawn-out online promo season where most shoppers know what’s real and what’s not. Consumers have price trackers, deal alerts, and a better sense of value now, so the “big event” has turned into a longer, more cautious buying window, especially given how tight money is for most people.
“For marketers, the focus should be on running an actual sale, not bumping prices up in October just to drop them again in November. If the discount’s genuine and the product’s worth it, the sale will perform. But fake urgency just damages trust. The DFS-style “endless sale” approach might fill a short-term revenue gap, but it erodes credibility over time.
When it comes to balancing short-term performance with long-term brand health during something like Cyber Week, it’s about staying consistent with who you are. Don’t chase volume if it means cheapening the brand. Use the period to reward loyal customers, test new messaging, or move stock that fits your brand narrative. Quick wins are fine, but make sure they feed into a longer-term plan rather than creating a one-week sugar rush.”
Cyber Week planning used to be a media moment. Now it is an operational moment. Inventory, pricing, creative, journeys, payments and service all need to move as one. AI and automation sit across the stack, from asset generation to bidding and routing. The discipline is to put brand and unit economics at the centre, then let automation do the lifting.
Beth Moore, Door4, starts every plan with a blunt question: What is the business actually trying to achieve in the window?
Beth continues, “Every strategy and plan should start with the question of what is the objective: are you shifting stock at any cost, investing to acquire retainable customers, or rewarding loyalty? Yet we also need to keep in mind, another layer of complexity – Brands are increasingly wary of training their customers to wait for discounts, effectively cannibalising their own October and early November sales as shoppers who would have purchased anyway simply hold off. The plans would look completely different depending on your core objective, and the most successful brands we partner with have the discipline to balance short-term Cyber Week performance against both long-term business objectives and protecting full-price sales in the critical run-up period.”
So we start with choices. Do you defend margin and reward loyal customers, or is this a stock clearance play? If you want net new customers, are they likely to retain at full price. This clarity drives everything downstream, from channel mix to creative and bid caps.
Media buying tactics have shifted from blanket pressure to precise sequencing. Smart accounts set rules based on inventory depth, contribution margin, and expected lifetime value, not just ROAS. AI-powered bidding is now table stakes, but it only shines when fed with clean signals and bounded by business rules.
Our take at Door4 is simple. Efficiency beats crude cost-cutting. Use automation to remove waste, but choose value over volume when it comes to audiences and placements. That means tighter exclusions, smarter lookbacks, and on-the-day agility driven by live product and profit feeds.
AI is increasingly pragmatic in media stacks. Think creative variants generated to fit formats and audiences, predictive budgets that rebalance hourly, and decisioning that pauses a hero SKU when stock flags turn red. The human operators focus on intent, narrative, and exceptions. Machines do the plodding work of pacing, matching and testing.
Economic uncertainty has reshaped behaviour. Shoppers delay, compare, and pounce when value is clear. Free delivery can beat a thin discount. Bundles can protect margin while giving a bigger perceived win.
Thijs Bijl, Analyst at Door4, shared a live example that leans into this trade-off.
We have an automotive client that doesn’t usually do any form of discounting. This is to protect the brand and avoid training customers to wait for a discount. The product is usually seen as a distress purchase, which means a discount isn’t as powerful as for impulse purchases. We still want to capitalise on the Black Friday period and the ‘purchasing state of mind’ people get in. The challenge was to think of an appropriate Black Friday discount that will give customers the feeling of saving money, whilst protecting the brand and avoid devalueing the product.
“We came up with 3 types of discounts that aren’t a simple percentage off the total order, like many sales. Option 1 is free delivery on all orders. Option 2 is to offer free delivery for bundles only. This helps increase AOV while still offering a discount. Option 3 is to only discount the largest bundles; this is also designed to offer value to the customer while increasing AOV. It’s up to the client to choose an option so we can carry on the BFCM plan”
There is a clear lesson here. If the category is a distress purchase, a slashed price may not change conversion much. If the category is discretionary, a strong price anchor or limited-time bonus might move the needle. Either way, the premium sits with transparency and the customer’s sense of a fair deal.
Conversion rate optimisation is the quiet workhorse in this mix. During Cyber Week, it is less about wholesale redesign and more about friction hunting. Streamline delivery promises, clarify returns, pre-load vouchers, and simplify payment. Tiny wins across these points can deliver more than a flashy acquisition push.
SEO, PPC and CRO should not be separate islands during Cyber Week. SEO shapes the pre-sale discovery and the trust layer. PPC wins the fast skirmishes. CRO turns attention into revenue. When these are integrated, you get compounding effects. Organic pages set the narrative and schema, paid traffic piggybacks the language and offer logic, and the onsite experience closes the loop with coherence.
AI helps to align messages and timing. It can map search trends to creative variants, sync email and paid social cadences, and ensure onsite banners reflect real stock and delivery cut-offs. The win looks like this. A user sees consistent language across channels, relevant products in stock, and a checkout that feels designed for the moment.
As Tom said earlier, trust is the hard currency. Integrated channels create that sense of reliability under pressure.
It is tempting to think Cyber Week is all harvest and no sowing. Binet and Field’s 60/40 split is a reminder that demand creation and demand capture feed each other. The split is not a law, but the idea stands. Strong brand presence reduces price elasticity and improves paid efficiency.
During Cyber Week, you can build brand while you sell. Use the moment to show what you stand for. Reward loyalty openly. Be honest about limits. Keep creative distinct, not generic. A buyer who smells values and competence will forgive the scrum. A buyer who smells trickery will remember for all the wrong reasons.
Beth’s warning about training customers to wait is really a brand point. If you condition your audience to see you as a discount brand, the long-term price is steep. The most resilient brands sell value and clarity first, then skilfully package a deal around that core.
Innovation does not need a lab coat. The best teams ship tiny experiments that de-risk bigger bets. At Door4, we use an Art of the Possible framework to map ideas across the customer journey, then run 100-minute sprints to turn three of them into reality fast. The point is not perfection. It is to make, test and learn before the window heats up.
Here are three MVPs we have seen work in the wild.
Thijs’s Paintnuts example is an MVP mindset in action. Try three value frames that uphold the brand. Pick the winner. Scale it for the week.
This season teaches fast. Capture the learning while it is fresh, then bake it into 2026 plans. Treat AI as infrastructure rather than a gadget. That means standardised data flows, permissioned access, and clear processes for human review. It also means building a playbook for multi-modal content, since generative engines now sit between your brand and discovery in many contexts.
There is a growing case for generative engine optimisation. If customers ask assistants what to buy, your brand and product story need to be easy to summarise and verify. That leans on structured data, clear language, social proof, and an owned content hub that is both authoritative and human. Helpful beats clever here.
On the team side, close the gap between marketing, trading and service. Cyber Week exposes seams. Fix them now. Every improvement in stock accuracy, payments resilience or post-purchase communication will pay out all year.
Busy leaders like a short list. Here is one to run this week.
Cyber Week rewards the prepared. Not the loudest, not the cheapest, and not the bravest for its own sake. The prepared teams are honest about objectives, align channels around a single story, let automation do the heavy lifting, and protect the brand even when the clock is ticking.
Partnerships matter here. Agencies and tech providers who sit inside your numbers and your operations can move faster with you. Build working rhythms now. Share dashboards. Agree rules. And after the dust settles, debrief ruthlessly so that the next cycle is smarter from day one.
Our latest articles, features and ramblings.
We explore performance marketing, AI, communications and optimisation.
Black Friday and Cyber Week don’t really hold the same magic they used to. It’s gone from people queuing at 4am and fighting over TVs to afairly drawn-out online promo season where most shoppers know what’s real and what’s not. Consumers have price trackers, deal alerts, and a better sense of value now, so the “big event” has turned into a longer, more cautious buying window, especially given how tight money is for most people.
Cyber Week preparation must start with honesty in the business objectives, not just sales and revenue targets. In the past, I’ve seen brands celebrate record breaking Cyber Week sales only to realise they’ve decimated margins or filled their database with one-time customers who wanted a bargain.