When it comes to building a WordPress website, one of the most common dilemmas faced by developers, designers, and business owners is choosing between a custom WordPress theme or using a page builder. Each approach offers distinct advantages and drawbacks depending on your technical expertise, project goals, and long-term maintenance preferences. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both to help you make an informed decision.
A custom theme is developed specifically for a particular website, often coded from scratch or built using a minimal starter theme. This option is typically favoured by developers or those hiring a web agency for a highly tailored solution.
With a custom theme, you’re in charge of every aspect of the design and codebase. This allows you to implement unique layouts, custom features, and advanced functionality tailored to your brand.
Since there’s no unnecessary code or bloat, custom themes are often lighter and faster than page builder sites. You can optimise loading times, minimise plugin dependencies, and fine-tune every element for SEO and performance.
Custom themes encourage best practices and semantic HTML. A clean, well-documented codebase makes future updates and scaling easier, especially when multiple developers are involved.
Building a custom theme requires coding expertise and more development time, making it more expensive upfront. Small businesses with limited budgets may find this cost-prohibitive.
Unlike plug-and-play solutions, custom themes take longer to design, develop, test, and deploy. This can be a drawback for projects with tight timelines.
Any changes or fixes usually require a developer, which might not be ideal for non-technical site owners.
Page builders like Elementor, Beaver Builder, and WPBakery provide drag-and-drop interfaces that allow users to design websites visually without touching code.
Page builders are incredibly user-friendly. You don’t need coding knowledge to build or update pages, which empowers business owners and marketers to manage their sites directly.
You can quickly prototype and launch websites using pre-built templates and widgets. This is ideal for time-sensitive projects or MVPs.
For freelancers and small businesses, page builders provide a low-cost entry into custom-looking websites without the expense of hiring a developer.
Page builders often add extra layers of code, which can slow down your website. Poorly optimised builders or stacking multiple plugins can lead to sluggish performance.
While flexible, page builders have their limits. Truly unique designs or advanced functionality may be difficult or impossible to implement without custom coding.
Some page builders create proprietary shortcodes or elements. If you decide to switch builders or themes later, you may be left with broken layouts or messy content.
Choose a custom theme if you need full control, want top performance, and have access to a developer (or are one). It’s ideal for complex, high-traffic sites or businesses that value long-term scalability and branding.
Choose a Page Builder if you need to get online quickly, have a limited budget, or want the flexibility to manage your site without technical help. It’s perfect for portfolios, small business sites, and solopreneurs.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on your goals, resources, and technical skills. Understanding the trade-offs between custom themes and page builders is essential for building a site that meets your current needs and grows with you over time.
Author: Steve Dixon, Web Developer, Door4
Our latest articles, features and ramblings.
We explore performance marketing, AI, communications and optimisation.
